Skip Navigation | Sheffield IMC | UK IMC | Editorial Guidelines | Mission Statement | About Us | Contact | Help | Support Us

UK Indymedia UK Indymedia Sheffield Indymedia Sheffield Indymedia

Sheffield City Council reject the application from Tesco for Comonside: | 07.07.2009 17:49 | Sheffield

Another one bites the dust planning application no 09/00745/FUL was regceted at The West and North planning meeting, which was hold on the 7th July a room full of local people herd Sheffield City Council reject the application from Tesco.

TESCO put forward plans to build a new convenience store on the land between Springvale Road and Commonside. A similar proposal for the same site had already been rejected once this now being no 2. Across Sheffield there are currently numerous objections fi led by the local council, as well as petitions organised byconcerned residents.

The area between Walkley and Crookes (where the site rests) is somewhat unique for Sheffield – representing one of few areas as of yet untouched by the business of large corporations. The proposed development not only represents a threat to local business and an increased risk of traffic congestion but also threatens the unique character of this Sheffi eld suburb. Corporations like TESCO, ASDA and the other superstore giants do not care for social diversity, for community concerns or our local issues. They have one priority and one priority only – profit. Areas like Walkley and Crookes are simply swallowed up and transformed into clones of other British high streets before them – no choice, no diversity.

No Social Responibility.They also seriously threaten basic social amenities that are essential to any neighbourhood. In October 2002,TESCO bought 870 One Stop, Day & Night or Dillons shops across the UK, almost 1/2 of which contained a sub post office. TESCO is now busily converting these shops into TESCO Express, closing 100 post offi ces, often in the smallest communities, in the process. When

TESCO has attempted to branch out into community programmes it has proved deeply demeaning to the enduring efforts of well-meaning volunteers. “Community sponsorship” is a much needed luxury for cashstarved charities and enterprises.

However, it is always accompanied by the mandatory corporate stamp and logo. The most well-intentioned of projects are automatically opportunity for another PR exercise for the superstore giant. Bad for the environment. TESCO’s is not a responsible or ethical employer. It has repeatedly been exposed for its poor environmental record and its stores (in a study by Sheffi eld Hallam University) were found to be the most energy-ineffi cient in the sector. This is despite repeated claims by TESCO management that they are a “green” company. In fact, it would take more than 60 corner shops and greengrocers to match the carbon dioxide emissions from one average sized superstore. Bad for workers. Worldwide TESCO does not respect the right of workers to a fair wage, to decent working hours or a right to organize.

For example, in Turkey TESCO has had a history of engaging in union-busting campaigns. Pressure is put on union members to resign in the hopes that the company can push representation below fifty per cent and thus ignore worker representation rights. Even as union membership has grown well beyond the half-way level TESCO still contests recognition and refuses to meet with union leaders. In the UK, the major food retailers can exert undue pressure on suppliers causing job losses in food processing companies that simply cannot produce goods at the prices TESCO and their competitors wish to pay. In Chard in March 2006 local GMB activists organised a demonstration outside TESCO when the company pulling a contract from a local employer resulted in 850 job losses in the South West, and 500 in Chard alone. Time to make a difference. Plans to build a convenience store in your neighbourhood may seem trivial at first (and this is exactly how companies like TESCO want it to appear). But the issues exposed have the potential to seriously impair community life. Corporations like TESCO thrive on indifference and apathy towards their policies. So, let’s force on them the accountability and the scrutiny they deserve. Let us defend what we have here and not allow Walkley to become yet another bland outlet, a clone high street in “superstore Britain”.

5 things you ought to know about Tesco superstore:

1. TESCO does not provide good jobs for local people. TESCO supermarket jobs are low paying, have long hours and shop stewards have reported trouble in getting workers on to company pensions schemes. TESCO has categorically stated for past Sheffield developments that it does not intend to hire its “high skilled” (and higher paying) labour from the local area.

2. TESCO is bad for the environment. TESCO transports millions of tonnes of produce around the world, contributing to climate change through transport emissions. A 2005 Friends of the Earth survey found that TESCO came lowest out of the supermarket chains for sourcing British apples. TESCO stores are also the most environmentally inefficient in the sector.

3. TESCO exploits workers worldwide. Women in Bangladesh making clothes for TESCO and ASDA earn as little as 5p an hour working 14 hours a day. Workers in Costa Rica producing bananas for export to all major UK supermarkets earn 33p an hour - a wage so low that they cannot afford to take an hour off when dangerous pesticides are being sprayed on the crops. There are countless other examples of TESCO’s negligence towards its workers poverty wages, poor working conditions and supplier’s union-busting campaigns.

4. TESCO kills community life. Despite its commitment towards “community sponsorship”, TESCO has a poor record working with communities. TESCO creates neither choice nor convenience. It removes the diversity of social life outside the superstore and clutters the streets with waste and traffi c. The corporation uses its disproportionate (and unchecked) economic power to manipulate political influence and regional control to its own shareholders ends.

5. TESCO already has five other stores within walking distance – West Street, Infi rmary Road, Fulwood Road, Southey and Ecclesall (not to mention other companies

They will no doubt apeal and we need to rady for when they do so,here is what Sheffield Green Party has said:

It is good to see local people and councillors objecting to a further bid for a Tescos on Commonside ('New Bid For Supermarket' The Star 30th March.) What a pity that councillors on the City Centre and East Planning Board supported the application for a Tescos on Abbeydale Road against the expressed wishes of local people? Why did the LibDems vote in Council against a plea by the Federation of Small Businesses to stop supermarkets driving independent local stores out of business?

Supermarket chains drive out local independent businesses and dominate our high-streets. In championing choice, local communities are strangled and left with no choice. They control over 80% of the food business, seriously damaged small farmers and growers and increase road traffic. The claim that they create jobs does not bear close examination. They have hoodwinked both the Competition Commission and the Office of Fair Trading and halted the recommended Code of Practice.

Sheffield Green Party will continue to campaign at both a local and city wide level to bring back the control of our high streets to local people. We will encourage people to use the new powers they have through the Sustainable Communities Act to stop the destruction of our local shopping centres.

With proper regulation the real costs of our food system will be reflected in the price paid at the check-out and we will see the back of these clone town creating bullies.

Yours Sincerely

Bernard Little.
Green Party Prospective Parliamentary Candidate for Sheffield
Central Constituency

TESCO was last year granted permission for another Express store in Sheffield Councillors at Sheffield Council’s City Centre, South and East Planning and Highways Area Board agreed by a narrow margin of five to four to allow the shopping giant to use the former car showroom on the corner of Abbeydale Road and Bedale Road. Permission came despite dozens of letters of objection and two petitions with more than 1,100 names, this store is now open:

RESIDENTS of the Parkhead area of Sheffield are keeping up the pressure on the council to reject plans for a Tesco Express store. A petition with 1,800 names was submitted to the Town Hall on the 24 October 2008 , objecting to an application to redevelop the site of the old Parkhead garage in Ecclesall Road South.
TESCO is preparing to open two more stores in the south west of Sheffield. Plans for one of its convenience stores in Abbeydale are being recommended for council approval (April , 2009), despite widespread objections about the impact on existing shops. The supermarket giant is opening stores across Sheffield – the one befor in Barnsley Road – saying that they fulfil a need for convenient ‘top-up’ shopping. But critics claim they are squeezing out local shops, concerns raised by protesters trying to halt the proposed development on the site of the former Autoworld car showroom at the corner of Abbeydale Road and Bedale Road, near the old Abbeydale Cinema (now open). The area is already well served by a diverse range of shops and supermarkets, some of which have been trading for 30 years, it is argued.

The latest plans for TESCO’s mixed-use development at the corner of Spital Hill and Savile Street have been submitted to the Council’s planning board following amendments to their design. The proposals include a 10,000 square metre supermarket, four storey offices, a car park and several ‘neighbourhood retail units’. This will create an unbroken commercial development that will wrap around the old Hartwells site and up Spital Hill, finishing at a new public space below the East House pub. It is hoped the new store will provide several hundred new jobs with 200 of these earmarked for the long-term unemployed.

TESCO’s architects have re-drafted their initial plans after officials expressed concern that the designs lacked integration with the existing buildings, particularly the historic Wicker Arches. Although many residents are in favour of the new store, objections have been raised against the planned closing-off of Carlisle Street which some residents have said will increase their journey times and effect local buses. Tesco believes this measure will improve access to the supermarket entrance. If the Council gives its approval, the store could open at the end of 2010.

RESIDENTS in a Sheffield suburb have condemned supermarket giant Tesco for ruining their quality of life with disruptive delivery lorries. People living near the Tesco Express store on Abbeydale Road South at Totley Rise say the store has blighted their life with huge, noisy lorries often clogging up local streets.It comes as councillors at Sheffield Council agreed to allow the store to receive deliveries on Sundays and Bank Holidays.

Under the terms of the store’s original planning consent deliveries on Sundays and Bank Holiday were prohibited – to allow locals to have some peace and quiet. But the store argued it had to have deliveries on these days too to keep it well stocked. The move was opposed by Sheffield Hallam MP and Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg, a 173-name petition and the council received 55 letters of objection. Brian Stubbs, aged 61, of Devonshire Road, who lives around the corner from the store, told the meeting:

“Tesco seems to be like a magnet. It is almost like they are giving food away free. People come from all around.”Planning officer Chris Heeley said the suggested changes were a “reasonable compromise”. But the meeting’s chairman suggested amending the proposed changes to 10.30am to 6.30pm on Sundays and Bank Holidays, with Monday to Saturday deliveries as originally proposed, and the suggestion was carried.

Mr Stubbs condemned the decision and said: “Who will police this? Tesco just do what they like.”It is not just about the noise of deliveries, it is about parking. People park on double yellow lines, on verges, but when the big delivery lorries are there it is just much, much worse.”Neighbour Ian Cockburn, 60, also of Devonshire Road, added: “Tesco has dramatically altered our quality of life. It’s pathetic.”


Hide the following 6 comments

Mozaz - thief

08.07.2009 18:37

Where did you rip that non-attributed piece from Mozaz? Either attribute, write, or (preferably) go away please. You still doing that real working class multi £K job in the cultural industries quarter?


more from tesco

09.07.2009 09:33

There are plans to create yet another Tesco shop, a mile away from the superstore off Abbeydale Road. This is clearly ludicrous!

State your objection here:

Oh dear me more disinfo from inside indymedia, fucking k job indeed not we would even wish ta very much..

one source

09.07.2009 14:55

At least part of that (the 5 quick facts) seems to come from a piece from


bollocka aint it:

09.07.2009 18:17

To rip apart some good news for a change, if you read the whole or bother looking further you would see they have given links to the info try but then it is beeter to spin dis info than truth, better to keep up the wrongs of the working class than give any fucking praise for the positive there doing, divide rule The Middle Class keep there social position, what if the working class of commonside also objected to Tesco:

This one article that has no images so the toy town anarchist can not have shame, moomy and daddy will not KNOW that there being little rebels, just where did afed get the info try here Christ the dis info wankers are somewhat tiresome, did we see any at the meeting when this was turned down will we see any at future actions? Of course not they will be to fucking busy with there own self importance:

Credit where credit is due

10.07.2009 09:36

Mozaz, a while back you were having a go because we used one of your pictures in Fargate without credit. We apologised. Now stop ripping off our news pieces and not only attributing them to yourself (which wouldn't be so bad) but actually using them against us! None of us were at the planning meeting because we were working (it was 2 in the afternoon), we are very pleased with the outcome obviously. Although we also clearly acknowledge that a council planning meeting is going to secure nothing in the long term. We need community, direct action to permanently secure the space. Against TESCO and against the council and political party hacks who were eager to exploit community interest in this issue. We say as much here - (I anticipate seeing this mis-attributed in a jumbled-up format on Indymedia any day now)

Sheffield Anarcho
- Homepage:

10.07.2009 10:04

all good and there are thoughts and plans for further action and we hope to see you there involved, but read the article, indymedia needs a change i.e. log in so the disnfo merchants can not play there game and to let html code to be written, if you goto you will note it has been given the credit as we use word press it means we can write in html and give links, here dose not permit, yes I could have done {notes} now in hindsight I wish I had done so.

but we all fuck from time to time and this was the point I was making, some of your comrades are middle class, do sit in judgement of the working class, so do we we regards the middle class but for good sound political reasons, none of the crass comments or lies spun about me are based on sound political reasons there disnfo a means to divide the working class and weaken them, we should indeed celebrate this.

but also understand they will come back for more with this in mind underclassrising have been speaking to locals (we are locals it might be noted) with some thoughts on future action, one last attributing them to yourself would mean in my name i.e. Mark Mozaz Wallis there in the name of see it very clear there it is not one person we are an anarchist collective.

we share our incomes and work together on the principals of anarchism, if the rest of them disagree with what and how I represent the group then one is accountable to them, shame this is not the same for some of your comrades who to be frank do go around spreading lies rumours and disinfo, we do not enter into such bullshit as it we know it weakens us as anarchist, we act to build a mass working class movement, this can only be done from a platform of being honest, so we are open to say we have fucked up in the past, but this is not about that but the impact tesco would have on the people of commonside, and speaking for myself I wish I lived there..

M M Wallis:


South Coast

Other UK IMCs
Bristol/South West
Northern Indymedia

Sheffield Topics

Animal Liberation
Climate Chaos
Energy Crisis
Free Spaces
Ocean Defence
Other Press
Public sector cuts
Social Struggles
Terror War
Workers' Movements

Sheffield [navigation.actions2016]

Sheffield [navigation.actions2015]

Sheffield [navigation.actions2014]

NATO 2014

Sheffield Actions 2013

G8 2013

Sheffield Actions 2012


Sheffield Actions 2011

2011 Census Resistance
August Riots
Dale Farm
J30 Strike
Occupy Everywhere

Sheffield Actions 2010

Flotilla to Gaza
Mayday 2010
Tar Sands

Sheffield Actions 2009

COP15 Climate Summit 2009
G20 London Summit
Indymedia Server Seizure
University Occupations for Gaza

Sheffield Actions 2008

2008 Days Of Action For Autonomous Spaces
Campaign against Carmel-Agrexco
Climate Camp 2008
G8 Japan 2008
Smash EDO
Stop Sequani Animal Testing
Stop the BNP's Red White and Blue festival

Sheffield Actions 2007

Climate Camp 2007
DSEi 2007
G8 Germany 2007
Mayday 2007
No Border Camp 2007

Sheffield Actions 2006

April 2006 No Borders Days of Action
Art and Activism Caravan 2006
Climate Camp 2006
French CPE uprising 2006
G8 Russia 2006
Lebanon War 2006
March 18 Anti War Protest
Mayday 2006
Oaxaca Uprising
Refugee Week 2006
Rossport Solidarity
Transnational Day of Action Against Migration Controls
WSF 2006

Sheffield Actions 2005

DSEi 2005
G8 2005
WTO Hong Kong 2005

Sheffield Actions 2004

European Social Forum
FBI Server Seizure
May Day 2004

Sheffield Actions 2003

Bush 2003
DSEi 2003
Evian G8
May Day 2003
No War F15
Saloniki Prisoner Support
Thessaloniki EU
WSIS 2003

Server Appeal Radio Page Video Page Indymedia Cinema Offline Newsheet

secure Encrypted Page

You are viewing this page using an encrypted connection. If you bookmark this page or send its address in an email you might want to use the un-encrypted address of this page.

If you recieved a warning about an untrusted root certificate please install the CAcert root certificate, for more information see the security page.


satellite tv


estrecho / madiaq
la plana
northern england
nottingham imc
united kingdom

Latin America
chile sur
cmi brasil
cmi sucre
puerto rico


South Asia

United States
hudson mohawk
kansas city
minneapolis/st. paul
new hampshire
new jersey
new mexico
new orleans
north carolina
north texas
rogue valley
saint louis
san diego
san francisco
san francisco bay area
santa barbara
santa cruz, ca
tampa bay
united states
western mass

West Asia


fbi/legal updates
mailing lists
process & imc docs